Tunnel pressure consists of (fig. 1):

sl181

Fig. 1. Pressure forces acting on the tunnel

a) the vertical pressure P at the crown, called crown pressure,

b) horizontal pressure S, called lateral pressure,

c) reactions at the base A, called base pressure.

The magnitude of earth pressure on a tunnel varies within very wide limits. Initially, during tunnel excavation, the mountain pressure is relatively small and ranges from 0 to 0,50 kp/cm2, but after excavation it increases and ranges from 0,8 to 12,0 kp/cm2, depending on the type of soil and its physical properties, the height of the strata above the tunnel, and the magnitude of movements in the soil that arise as a consequence of the pressure of the overlying layers. Because it depends on various factors, determining the mountain pressure on a tunnel is considerably more difficult, so the exact value of earth pressure cannot be determined theoretically, only an approximate one. The internal resistance of the soil opposes the action of earth pressure on the tunnel profile. If the soil in which the tunnel is being built consists of solid and compact rock, the pressure on the tunnel profile is negligible, because the load of the layers above the tunnel is carried by the shear stress of the solid rock. In such a case, it is not necessary to build tunnel lining or support during tunnel excavation, and determining the earth pressure on the tunnel profile is also unnecessary.

In non-compacted and friable rocks, the pressure caused by the weight of the upper layers on the tunnel profile may exceed the strength of such rocks, resulting in ground failure and severe deformations in the tunnel profile. In such cases, support should be installed during tunnel excavation, and then a tunnel lining should be made to resist the mountain pressure and transfer it through the foundation to the lower layers.

In cohesive soil, internal resistance consists of cohesion and friction, whereas in non-cohesive soil it consists only of friction without cohesion. However, given the variable value of cohesion under the influence of moisture, as well as the layering of soil of different composition, cohesion is not taken into account as internal resistance, so even in cohesive soil only internal friction is considered. Therefore, in both of these latter cases a tunnel lining is required, which means that the earth pressure on the tunnel must be determined.

For determining the magnitude of earth pressure on a tunnel, the following assumptions are made:

  1. Assumption that earth pressure increases proportionally with depth

  2. Assumption based on the laws of equilibrium of loose bodies

  3. Assumption on the formation of the relieving arch in the soil

  4. Assumption based on the laws of elasticity.

Assumption that pressure increases proportionally with depth

According to this assumption, the tunnel vault (fig. 2) is subjected to crown pressure P due to the weight of the soil over the entire height above the tunnel up to the ground surface, over the width of the excavated tunnel b. Therefore, the crown pressure is

P = γ bt [Mp/m]

where γ is the unit weight of the soil layers above the tunnel [Mp/m3], t is the height of the soil layers above the tunnel [m].

This assumption is adopted only in special cases, such as when the soil above a tunnel consists of mud that has almost no internal resistance, or when it is made up of cohesive and noncohesive soil in groundwater, when the soil resistance is less than the effect of the soil’s weight.

Such cases are rare in practice and are treated as special cases. In all other cases, when internal soil resistance can be taken into account, determining earth pressure on tunnels on this assumption is not justified, because it gives much greater pressure than the actual one.

sl182

Fig. 2. Determination of earth pressure on a tunnel under the assumption that pressure increases proportionally with depth

Assumption based on the laws of equilibrium of brittle bodies

Determination of earth pressure on a tunnel according to the assumption based on the laws of equilibrium of loose bodies

Fig. 3. Determination of earth pressure on a tunnel based on the assumption founded on the laws of equilibrium of cohesionless bodies

According to this assumption, dry loose soil is considered and it is assumed that the pressure on the tunnel vault is less than the weight of the prism ABA’B’ due to the action of frictional force on the vertical surfaces AA’ and BB’ (fig. 3).

On this assumption, several formulas for calculating the pressure on the tunnel vault are based, such as those by Forcheimer, Bierbaumer, and Engesser.

The total weight of the soil above the tunnel vault is W= γ bt, but the prism ABA’B’ will not be able to slide downward freely, because this movement will be opposed by friction of the material on surfaces AA’ and BB’. If o is the angle of internal friction of the soil above the tunnel vault, the friction coefficient is tgo, and the normal pressure on the friction surface is in fact the lateral force E, the active earth pressure on surfaces AA’ and BB’. Therefore, friction force acts on each of these surfaces

Q = Ea tg_ϕ._

The pressure P on the arch of the tunnel, the crown pressure, is

iz194

The active earth pressure is calculated according to Rankine

Ea = ½ γt2 tg2(45o – ϕ/2)

The determination of earth pressure on a tunnel according to this assumption is carried out rarely and only in certain cases, such as when the height of the soil layers above the tunnel is small, so that a relieving arch cannot form.

Assumption on the formation of the relieving arch

According to this method, in every coherent and incoherent soil, except in mud, a relief arch forms above the tunnel, so that only the material beneath that arch acts on the tunnel profile, while the arch itself is kept in equilibrium by arch action, which has been proven by tests in loose sandy soil. For determining earth pressure on a tunnel according to this assumption, there are several methods, the best known being the Kommerell and Protodyakonov methods. In the Kommerell method, the relieving arch is assumed to have the shape of a semi-ellipse, and in the Protodyakonov method, the shape of a parabola.

Kommerell’s method of the pressure semi-ellipse

According to this method, it is assumed that the height h of the relieving arch depends on the tunnel width and on the soil internal friction angle in which the tunnel is driven (fig. 4). The height of the relieving arch h can be determined on the basis of the formula:

h = 100_a_/p

where a is the settlement of the support from the beginning of tunneling to the completed masonry of the tunnel lining, p permanent looseness of the soil.

sl184

Fig. 4. Determination of earth pressure on a tunnel by the pressure semi-ellipse method

Under favorable conditions, a = 10 – 15cm is adopted; under unfavorable conditions, a = 15 – 40cm; under very unfavorable conditions, a = 40 – 70cm.

The permanent loosening of soil p is determined on the excavated tunnel soil in % after excavation and re-compaction. The values for p fall within the limits given in table 1.

However, although the above formula has been used fairly often in practice, it is considered not to correspond to reality. Settlement has no absolute value, but in one and the same material it differs according to the type of support. If the support is steel, settlement is smaller; if it is timber, settlement is greater. For normal tunnel profiles on railway lines and roads, for heights of soil cover above the tunnel t > 20 m, it is assumed that the height of the relieving arch h= 20 m.

Lateral pressure_. According to Kommerell, lateral pressure arises from the action of the weight of the earth prism ABC (fig. 4), which is bounded on the sides by the sliding surface AC and the vertical plane of the tunnel AB, while on the top it is loaded by the weight of the earth prism CBG. It is assumed that the active earth prism is bounded at the top by the horizontal surface CB in the plane of the tunnel crown

Table of approximate values of temporary and permanent soil looseness in percent

Table 1. Approximate values of soil p in %

Since plane AB is vertical and plane CB horizontal, it is assumed that the Rankine earth pressure case applies, and that the direction of the active earth pressure E is horizontal. According to Rankine, the inclination of the slip surface AC to the horizontal is at angle α=45o+ϕ/2, the active earth pressure Ea is

Ea = ½ _γh_2tg2(45o-ϕ/2),

where γ is the unit weight of the soil in Mp/m3, h is the height of the retaining wall in m, ϕ is the angle of internal friction of the soil.

Since the active earth prism ABC is loaded from above by the weight of the prism CBG, for the tunnel height h’ this will be

Ea = ½ γ h’ 2tg2(45o-ϕ/2),

where γ1 = γ + 2p/h’

where p = Q/CB = Q/h’tg(45o- ϕ/2)

The weight Q is obtained as the difference between the weight W of the quarter of the pressure ellipse CEF and the weight of W1:Q = W – W1.

The weight W is obtained from the area A of a quarter ellipse and the unit weight of the soil γ, W = Aγ. The area A is obtained from the ellipse area equation: A = h·e·π/4

By inserting the value of p into the equation for Ea we obtain:

Ea = ½ γ h’2 tg2 (45o-ϕ/2) + Q tg(45o-ϕ/2).

Crown pressure. Since the load-relief vault is symmetrical about the vertical axis, the crown pressure can be calculated for half of the tunnel profile. The weight of W1 of the soil prism BEFG for a tunnel length of 1,00 m is:

W1 = (z+h)/2 · b/2 · 1,00 · γ

In this equation everything is known except z, which we determine on the basis of the ellipse equation (fig. 5): b2x2 + a2y2 = b2a2. In our case b=e; a=h; x=z;

iz196

sl185

Fig. 5. Determination of crown pressure on a tunnel by the semi-ellipse load method

sl186

Fig. 6. Base pressure p beneath a support

Sill pressure. Since it is assumed that the sill pressure A is equal to the ridge pressure P, its magnitude is thereby determined.

If the tunnel profile has an invert arch, the pressure at the tunnel bottom p is: p = P/(b·1,00m) [Mp/m2].

However, if it is firm and has sufficiently high bearing capacity, the ridge pressure P is transferred to the ground by supports of width d (fig. 6), and the footing pressure beneath the supports is: p = P/(2d·1,00m) [Mp/m2].

It should be noted that in this case it is necessary to carry out site investigation and determine the bearing capacity and settlement of the soil, because there have been cases where the bearing capacity of the soil was lower than the bearing pressure, which led to deformation of the tunnel lining and settlement of the entire tunnel.

Assumption based on the laws of elasticity

In recent times, a new assumption has appeared, according to which soil is viewed as a homogeneous elastic isotropic body to which the laws of elasticity can be applied. According to this assumption, the elastic properties of soil are expressed by its modulus of elasticity E and Poisson’s coefficient µ, which depends on the physical properties of the soil. However, in reality soil is not isotropic, but an anisotropic mass, whose values of modulus E and coefficient µ change with depth. Nevertheless, despite this deviation, the application of elasticity theory for determining earth pressure is of great scientific interest and offers prospects for future investigations.

Examination of the stability of tunnel lining under earth pressure

To examine the stability of the tunnel lining, a cross-section of the lining is selected, and it is useful to use examples of tunnels previously built under similar conditions as in the given case, which have remained in good condition, or else the cross-section of the tunnel lining is determined by some empirical method (Fig. 7a). The selected cross-section of the tunnel lining is divided into lamellas, preferably of equal width Δs. For each lamella, the vertical and lateral pressure, as well as the weight of the lamella itself, are determined.

The vertical pressure PG on a strip for a tunnel length of 1,00 m (fig. 7a) is obtained on the basis of the formula:

PG = (y1+y2)/2 · Δ_x_·1,00·γ

sl187

Fig. 7. Determination of earth pressure on a tunnel by Kommerll’s method

The lateral pressure consists of the earth pressure Eh, on the tunnel profile of height h’ and the pressure Ea due to the action of the load Q

Eh’ = ½ γ h’2 tg2 (45o-ϕ/2); Ea = Q tg(45o-ϕ/2).

To determine the lateral pressures Eh on individual lining strips, the lateral pressure diagram (7a) is applied based on the equations:

iz198

The forces PG and Eh act along the axes of the respective lamellae.

In addition, the weight of the lining segment PZ is determined, acting at its centroid, and the resultant R of all forces on the given segment is found (fig. 7b). In this way, the resultants R1, R2, R3 are determined for all segments (fig. 8a), which are arranged in the force diagram (fig. 8b), thereby yielding the resultant Rn. Then, from an arbitrary pole O, rays are drawn and the first supporting line ac is drafted. From the condition that the arch is in equilibrium if the horizontal thrust of the arch H, the resultant earth pressure on the tunnel R_n and the footing pressure A intersect at one point, we obtain the intersection point S. If this point is connected with the midpoint of the arch springing joint, we obtain the direction of the new footing pressure A1. If the forces Rn, A1 and H are composed into a new force diagram (fig. 8c), we obtain the magnitude H and the new pole O1 from which new rays are drawn and the second supporting line ac’.

sl188

Fig. 8 Force diagram and supporting line of earth pressure on the tunnel

According to the newly obtained line of support, the cross-section of the tunnel lining is adjusted, and the line of support is constructed, if necessary, a third time as well. The aim is to adopt such a shape of tunnel lining whose axis coincides with the line of support. In that case, only compressive stresses act in the lining. The compressive stress that occurs in any cross-section n – n of the tunnel lining (fig. 8) is obtained from the formula

iz198.2

where N is the normal component of the resultant Rn on the lining section n – n, obtained from the force diagram for that section; d is the thickness of the tunnel lining in section n – n; e is the eccentricity of the applied force N in the same section.

The compressive stress σ should be less than the allowable stress of the lining. For reinforced-concrete tunnel arches, this method is considered not sufficiently accurate, and the Spangerberg method is recommended.

© Kate Sheets / CC-BY-2.0 (via Wikimedia Commons) — Craggy Pinnacle Tunnel close-up on BRP.jpg · Cropped to preserve the target aspect ratio; Downsampled without enlargement; Converted to sRGB and embedded metadata removed; source original retained